| Could Carey Have Been President?
By Tom Deignan
Back in October a group of Irish activists got together for the same
reason a bunch of grizzled New York political veterans gathered just last
week — to remind everyone that former New York Governor Hugh L. Carey is
not only still alive, but kicking.
Last week, the 86 year-old Carey, a Brooklyn native credited with saving
New York City from bankruptcy in the mid-1970s, was technically honoured
for his unflinching opposition to the death penalty. But it gave New York
power brokers — as well as Carey — a chance reflect on a colourful Irish
American career that is far from over.
Say this for Carey — he does not shy away from monumental challenges.
Not only did he grapple with New York City’s wrecked finances by forcing
the city to tighten its belt by declaring that “the days of wine and roses
are over.”
He has also thrown himself into fatherhood like few others, raising a
total of 14 children (over two marriages) and 24 grandchildren. He also
wishes he ran for president and remains active in the Northern Ireland peace
process.
A few weeks back, Carey’s contribution to the peace effort in Northern
Ireland was hailed by the National Committee on American Foreign Policy.
Carey, as well as Sinn Fein President Gerry Adams, was given the William
J. Flynn Initiative for Peace award.
“Governor Hugh L. Carey needs no introduction to New Yorkers who salute
him for the leading role he played during the 1970s in rescuing New York
City from bankruptcy,” said a rep from the National Committee on American
Foreign Policy, a 30 year old group which dedicates itself to the resolution
of conflicts which threaten U.S. interests.

Previous winners of the William J. Flynn Award include former Senator
George J. Mitchell, the facilitator of Northern Ireland’s Good Friday Agreement,
and Mo Mowlam, the late British secretary of state for Northern Ireland.
“What is less widely known (about Carey) is the pioneering work that
Governor Carey performed in the pursuit of peace in Northern Ireland. In
the early 1980s, he denounced the use of violence as a means of bringing
about necessary political change in that fractured land.
“Governor Carey and other Irish American politicians such as Senator
Edward Kennedy, Senator Daniel Patrick Moynihan and House Speaker Tip O’Neill
became known as the Four Horsemen, although the end result of their work
was hardly apocalyptic. Instead, it produced an environment that is conducive
to the affirmation of life by encouraging investments in people, projects,
and the peace process.”
Born in Brooklyn to Dennis and Margaret (Collins) Carey, the former governor
fought in World War II before serving over a decade in Congress. A loyal
Democrat, he was elected governor in 1975 as New York City teetered on the
brink of financial ruin.
Having helped avert that catastrophe, Carey had serious thoughts of becoming
America’s second Irish Catholic president. Last week, Carey said one of
his greatest regrets was not challenging Jimmy Carter for the Democratic
nod in 1976.
However, his first wife had just died. This and the large family for
which he had to care made a White House run virtually impossible.
Instead, he stayed in the brutal boxing ring of state politics, earning
a reputation as a fierce liberal (much to the chagrin of some conservative
Irish Americans) who fought for the underdog.
But inevitably the rigors of Albany got to Carey and by 1982, having
won re-election once before, he chose not to run again.
Since then, whether it is Northern Ireland or various advocacy issues,
Carey has remained active in politics. The Irish Hunger Memorial in downtown
Manhattan, meanwhile, was a project of the Hugh L. Carey Battery Park City
Authority, suggesting the broader impact he’s had on both New York City
and Irish America.
What challenges lies ahead for Carey? Well, it appears he himself will
fill a hole historians should have long ago. He has been quoted as saying
he will begin writing his memoirs soon.
However, no one knows how this great Irish story will end just yet.
(Contact Sidewalks at
tomdeignan@earthlink.net.)
|